미국민사소송법상의 판결의 효력(Ⅰ) － 좁은 의미의 Res Judicata를 중심으로 － : Effect of the Judgment in the U.S. Civil Procedure (Ⅰ) － Focusing on Res Judicata in its narrow sense －
Effect of the Judgment in the U.S. Civil Procedure (Ⅰ) － Focusing on Res Judicata in its narrow sense －
- 주제(키워드) Res Judicata , Res Judicata in its narrow sense , claim preclusion , collateral estoppel , issue preclusion claim , the claim-splitting , valid judgment , final judgment , judgment on the merits , in privity , persons in a privity relationship , a transaction test , the primary rights theory , compulsory counterclaim , 판결의 효력 , 좁은 의미의 판결의 효력 , 청구배제효 , 부수적 금반언 , 쟁점배제효 , 청구 , 청구의 분할 , 유효한 판결 , 종국판결 , 본안에 관한 판결 , 특수한 이해관계 , 특별이해관계인 , 거래기준설 , 우선적 권리이론 , 강제적 반소 , Res Judicata , Res Judicata in its narrow sense , claim preclusion , collateral estoppel , issue preclusion claim , the claim-splitting , valid judgment , final judgment , judgment on the merits , in privity , persons in a privity relationship , a transaction test , the primary rights theory , compulsory counterclaim
- 발행기관 안암법학회
- 발행년도 2010
- 총서유형 Journal
- UCI G704-001922.2010..33.007
- KCI ID ART001487831
- 본문언어 한국어
초록/요약
In the U.S. Civil Procedure, as for effect of the judgment, there is a concept of Res Judicata. The Res Judicata consists of Res Judicata in its narrow sense and collateral estoppel. The former could be referred to as claim preclusion, and the latter as issue preclusion. Among these concepts of Res Judicata, this article analyzes Res judicata in its narrow sense, namely, claim preclusion. For that purpose, I first review the concept and the legal character of Res Judicata in its narrow sense (chapter Ⅱ). Then I examine three requirements of it including i) former judgment should be valid and final judgment on the merits (chapter Ⅲ), ii) parties to former judgment and the later judgment have to be identical (chapter Ⅳ), ⅲ) claims of both judgments must be identical (chapter Ⅴ). Continuously, I keep reviewing general contents of Res Judicata in its narrow sense by examining its effect (chapter Ⅵ) and exception in application of the concept (chapter Ⅶ). By analyzing contents of Res Judicata in its narrows sense, I intend to figure out similarities and differences between Korea and U.S. in Civil Procedure.
more